| 1 | Floatpoint | Emily Short | $400 US |
| 2 | The Primrose Path | Nolan Bonvouloir | $100 US and a free copy of Quest Pro and QuestNet Server Pro |
| 3 | The Elysium Enigma | Eric Eve | The Lost Treasures of Infocom |
| 4 | The Traveling Swordsman | Mike Snyder | $75 US |
| 5 | Moon-Shaped | Jason Ermer | A $50 gift certificate to Circuit City, Best Buy, or CompUSA |
| 6 | Delightful Wallpaper | Andrew Plotkin | A nearly-complete set of Perplex City cards |
| 7 | Legion | Jason Devlin | A signed paperback copy of Twisty Little Passages |
| 8 | Madam Spider's Web | Sara Dee | A $50 gift certificate to J!NX |
| 9 | Mobius | John Clemens | A hardcover copy of the Inform Designer's Manual |
| 10 | Unauthorized Termination | Richard Otter | Syberia II for Windows |
| 11 | Game Producer! | jason bergman | A $15 gift certificate to ThinkGeek or J!NX |
| 12 | The Sisters | revgiblet | A $15 gift certificate to ThinkGeek or J!NX |
| 13 | Star City | Mark Sachs | The Longest Journey for Windows |
| 14 | Strange Geometries | Phillip Chambers | No prize chosen |
| 15 | The Tower of the Elephant | Tor Andersson | No prize chosen |
| 16 | Aunts and Butlers | Robin Johnson | Two Infocomics, Lane Mastadon and Gamma Force, for the Apple II |
| 17 | Xen: The Hunt | Ian Shlasko | No prize chosen |
| 18 | Labyrinth | Samantha Casanova Preuninger | Two unopened packs of Wave 1-3 Perplex City cards |
| 19 | Requiem | david whyld | Gothic II for Windows |
| 20 | Carmen Devine: Supernatural Troubleshooter | Rob Myall | A $25 US gift certificate to Threadless |
| 21 | The Bible Retold | Justin Morgan and "Celestianpower" | No prize chosen |
| 22 | Another Goddamn Escape the Locked Room Game | Riff Conner | Polaris |
| 23 | Fight or Flight | Sean Krauss | A $25 gift certificate to mymusic.com |
| 24 | MANALIVE, A Mystery of Madness - I | Bill Powell | Four pre-constructed Magic: The Gathering decks |
| 25 | Hedge | Steven Richards | Darwinia for Windows |
| 26 | A Broken Man | Geoff Fortytwo | A Kingdom of Loathing t-shirt |
| 27 | Polendina | Christopher Lewis | No prize chosen |
| 28 | The Initial State | Matt Barton | A used copy of Enchanter |
| 29 | MANALIVE, A Mystery of Madness - II | Bill Powell | Four pre-constructed Magic: The Gathering decks |
| 30 | Pathfinder | Tony Woods | A new copy of The Final Reflection, by John M. Ford, and a $20 donation in the winner's name to the John M. Ford Book Endowment |
| 31 | The Apolcalypse Clock | GlorbWare | No prize chosen |
| 32 | Wumpus Run | Elfindor | No prize chosen |
| 33 | Ballymun Adventure | Brendan Cribbin | No prize chosen |
| 34 | Tentellian Island | Zack Wood | No prize chosen |
| 35 | Lawn of Love | Santoonie Corporation | No prize chosen |
| 36 | Beam | Madrone Eddy | No prize chosen |
| 37 | Enter the Dark | Peter R. Shushmaruk | No prize chosen |
| 38 | Green Falls | Paul Panks | No prize chosen |
| 39 | Sisyphus | Theo Koutz | No prize chosen |
| 40 | Visocica | Thorben Bürgel | No prize chosen |
| 41 | Simple Adventure | Paul Panks | No prize chosen |
| 42 | Fetter's Grim | Paul Panks | No prize chosen |
| 43 | PTGOOD 8*10^23 | Sartre Malvolio | No prize chosen |
