| 1 | Another Earth, Another Sky | Paul O'Brian | $250 |
| 2 | Till Death Makes a Monk-Fish Out of Me! | Mike Sousa & Jon Ingold | $100 |
| 3 | Photograph | Steve Evans | A $50 gift certificate to Borders |
| 4 | The Moonlit Tower | Yoon Ha Lee | Corel Graphics Suite 10 |
| 5 | Janitor | Peter Seebach & Kevin Lynn | A $50 Best Buy gift certificate |
| 6 | The PK Girl | Robert Goodwin | The Gabriel Knight Trilogy |
| 7 | TOOKiE'S SONG | Jessica Knoch | A year's subscription to Asimov's Science Fiction magazine |
| 8 | Fort Aegea | Francesco Bova | The Essential Fantastic Four, Volumes 1-3 |
| 9 | The Temple | Johan Berntsson | Lord of the Rings: The Collector's Gift Set |
| 10 | Jane | Joseph Grzesiak | $25 gift certificate to mymusic.com, Tower Records, Amazon.com, or CDNOW |
| 11 | MythTale | Temari Seikaiha | A $25 gift certificate to Amazon.com |
| 12 | Unraveling God | Todd Watson | The Masterpieces of Infocom |
| 13 | Augustine | Terrence V. Koch | A year's subscription to Collective Detective |
| 13 | Identity Thief | Rob Shaw-Fuller | The Illuminatus Trilogy |
| 15 | Rent-A-Spy | John Eriksson | A red oil lantern |
| 16 | The Granite Book | James Mitchelhill | The first season of The Sopranos |
| 16 | Eric's Gift | Joao Mendes | L-Topia |
| 18 | When Help Collides | J. D. Berry | Corel WebMaster Suite |
| 19 | Evacuate | Jeff Rissman | Wizard War |
| 19 | Constraints | Martin Bays | The Inform Designer's Manual |
| 21 | Sun and Moon | David Brain | $25 gift certificate to Feelies.org |
| 22 | Not Much Time | Tyson Ibele | A year's subscription to Collective Detective |
| 23 | Hell: A Comedy of Errors | John Evans | No prize chosen |
| 24 | Color and Number | Steven Kollmansberger | Two Pot Noodles |
| 24 | Out Of The Study | Anssi Raisanen | A Strange Breezes polo shirt |
| 26 | BOFH | Howard Sherman | No prize chosen |
| 27 | The Case of Samuel Gregor | Stephen Hilderbrand | A Santoonie Corporation Inc. shirt |
| 28 | A Party to Murder | David Good | $25 gift certificate to Feelies.org |
| 29 | Screen | Edward Floren | No prize chosen |
| 30 | Concrete Paradise | Tyson Ibele | A year's subscription to Collective Detective |
| 31 | Scary House Amulet! | Ricardo Dague | No prize chosen |
| 32 | coffee quest II | Anonymous | Trinity for the IBM PC |
| 33 | Four Mile Island | Chris Charla | Infidel, Journey, and Loom for the Amiga |
| 34 | Moonbase | Mike Eckardt | No prize chosen |
| 35 | Koan | Esa Peuha | Planetfall for the Apple IIe |
| 36 | Terrible Lizards | Alan and Ian Mead | No prize chosen |
| 36 | Ramon and Jonathan | Daniele A. Gewurz | Fallacy of Dawn feelie packet |
| 38 | Blade Sentinel | Mihalis Georgostathis | No prize chosen |
